Categories
Education

The Miller, His Son, and Me: How We Respond to Criticism

I have been thinking again recently about Aesop’s fable, The Miller, His Son and Their Ass. It’s a story I shared in my very first Serendipities post, reflecting on my parenting skills during lockdown. On that occasion, my attempts to keep everyone in the family happy ended rather badly, with me needing to see a chiropractor. You live and learn.

I seem to have learned very little, however, judging by the state of my Christmas tree after trying to accommodate everyone’s wishes this weekend. The brief was to keep it elegant, bling and traditional. It’s a total mess.

Anyway, about Aesop…

For those unfamiliar with the story, a miller and his son set off for market with their donkey. Along the way, they encounter various people who offer their opinions on how they should make their journey.

This is how it all went down:

When criticised for walking alongside the donkey rather than riding it, the miller puts his son on its back.

When criticised for allowing his son to ride while he walks, the miller takes his son’s place.

When criticised for making his young son walk while he rides, the miller invites his son to join him on the donkey.

And when criticised for making the donkey carry two people, they both get off and decide to carry the poor donkey instead.

Then, as they approach a bridge, all the commotion frightens the donkey, which breaks free and falls into the river.

– The end –

The moral of the story is probably familiar to you: if you try to please everyone, you can end up pleasing no one.

I have been wondering whether the story offers another lesson, particularly for those of us in leadership.

We often hear discussions about whether leaders are born or made. To save us some time here, the conclusion is usually a bit of both. But I’ve lately become more interested in a slightly different question: how do leaders change over time? How do our experiences shape our judgement, challenge our assumptions and influence the decisions we make?

Experience brings a greater appreciation of the art of trade-offs. We become better at anticipating the unintended consequences of our decisions and recognising the sometimes complicated relationship between cause and effect. And we can also develop a better sense of when caution is needed and when courage, perhaps even boldness, is called for. Sometimes we get it spot on; sometimes we get it spectacularly wrong. Hopefully, we can learn from both.

I think what I’m getting at is that experience, and the wisdom that hopefully comes with it, brings an understanding that our decisions will inevitably please some people and disappoint others. And I can think of many occasions, particularly in my earlier career, when I have tried to lead by pleasing.

I said earlier that we live and learn. But I also think we learn to live.

We learn to live with decisions that involve trade-offs. We learn to live with competing priorities, and we learn to live with the fact that the needs and wants of different individuals and groups won’t always align.

Our schools are particularly good places to see all this in action. Students, parents, teachers, leaders and the wider community all have their own ideas about what a school should be doing, and how and when. These perspectives will rarely pull in the same direction, perhaps compounded by the fact that almost everyone in a school community has been a student at some point and therefore arrives with their own idea of how education should work. And in a school like ours, where we have deliberately sought to build a diverse community by welcoming families from all corners of the world, those perspectives can be multiplied and sometimes further polarised.

Of course, understanding this complexity intellectually doesn’t make it any easier to lead. People have strong feelings about decisions that affect them, and quite reasonably so. They may disagree with our reasoning, question our priorities or simply be unhappy with the outcome.

You would think that if we gathered enough data, consulted widely and approached things with sufficient goodwill, we ought to be able to arrive at a decision that leaves everyone reasonably happy.

We can’t.

Wisdom is knowing that the pursuit of universal approval, or minimum dissatisfaction, will only make donkeys of us.

As I’ve been thinking about the different ways in which we respond to criticism, particularly when it challenges a decision we’ve made or a position we hold, I’ve noticed that we often default to three broad responses:

  1. Reactiveness
  2. Resistance (defensive)
  3. Reflectiveness

The reactive response is perhaps the strongest pull in our age.

As the miller and his son discovered, we live in a world where opinions are readily expressed, feedback is immediate and there is often an expectation of an almost instantaneous response. We are encouraged to acknowledge every concern, respond to every complaint and demonstrate that we have listened. None of this is necessarily a bad thing. Listening to people matters, and being accessible and responsive are important qualities in anyone who leads.

But I do wonder how easy it is to confuse our responsiveness with reactivity.

When a concern is raised, we feel compelled to act. Then, if someone subsequently expresses dissatisfaction with the decision we’ve made, we might begin to question whether we got it right. Feedback can expose things we’ve overlooked or challenge assumptions that need challenging. But not all feedback is equally valid, and not every criticism requires an immediate change of direction.

The second response to feedback is resistance, or defensiveness. This is perhaps the opposite instinct. We can find ourselves defending our original position, dismissing the criticism or finding reasons why the person offering the feedback has misunderstood the situation. We can become more interested in justifying the decision than considering whether it might actually need to change.

In my experience, a defensive response almost always lands poorly. In schools, it can leave a parent or student feeling that they haven’t been heard, and mistrust begins to fester.

There are occasions when criticism is misplaced or poorly informed. But it would be a mistake to assume that our original thinking is necessarily right simply because we’ve invested time and energy in reaching a particular conclusion.

If the miller had been resistant rather than reactive to the criticism he received, I imagine he would have defended his original decision. He might have explained why walking was perfectly sensible, why his son could ride the donkey, and why the animal was more than strong enough to carry the load. He might even have had some good arguments. But he would have been so intent on defending his position that he would have given little consideration to whether any of the criticism was justified.

The third response is reflective.

This involves taking a step back, listening properly and considering what has been said. It means being prepared to examine our assumptions and think about the wider implications. Sometimes we’ll change our minds. Other times, after considering the criticism, we’ll conclude that our original decision remains the right one.

If the miller had been reflective in his response to the criticism he received, I imagine he would have listened carefully to what people were saying, considered whether there was any merit in their observations and tried to understand what might be sitting underneath the criticism. He might have recognised that some people had a point, while others were simply expressing a passing opinion. He might have changed his mind on some occasions, while deciding on others that his original approach was perfectly reasonable. But rather than letting every passing opinion determine his next move, he would have taken the time to consider what was right for the journey, his son, and the donkey.

I suspect most of us have experienced all three responses at different times. I certainly recognise each of them in myself, even over the last week. There have been occasions when I’ve been too quick to respond to criticism, perhaps because I wanted to resolve the discomfort rather than properly consider the issue. There have also been occasions when I’ve been more resistant than I’d care to admit.

I think the important thing is to recognise when we’re reacting rather than thinking. The reflective response doesn’t mean we always get things right, but it gives us a better chance of making a considered decision when we are open to the question, “What am I missing?”

Ultimately, after listening, considering, and reflecting, we still have to make a decision. Sometimes that will mean changing our minds. Other times, it will mean explaining why, after considering the feedback, we believe our original decision remains the right one.

Neither outcome should be driven by a desire to avoid discomfort or defend our original position. Both require us to exercise judgement and, importantly, to take responsibility for the consequences.

The miller could have done with more leadership wisdom. He didn’t need to ignore the people he encountered, nor did he need to follow every piece of advice. He simply needed to exercise a little more judgement about which opinions deserved his attention and which were best left behind.

I think there’s something in this for all of us who lead. We should listen carefully, seek out different perspectives and be prepared to change our minds.

Leadership involves making decisions that not everyone will agree with. Sometimes the right decision is unpopular. Sometimes, despite our best efforts, somebody is going to be disappointed.

That’s part and parcel of taking on leadership.

Ultimately, I feel the real lesson of Aesop’s fable is that we need to be a little more discerning about which voices we allow to influence our decisions.

If we spend all our time responding to what everyone else thinks we should be doing, we might eventually lose sight of what we were trying to do in the first place.

I know I’ve been guilty of that. There have been times when I’ve changed direction because someone made a sufficiently convincing argument, only to find myself wondering afterwards why I’d changed course in the first place.

We won’t always get it right, and we’ll probably continue to make a few donkeys of ourselves along the way. But hopefully, with a little more experience, we will get better at recognising when we’re doing it.


Discover more from Serendipities

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Serendipities

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading